This page provides a side-by-side comparison of the three most widely referenced mercury detox protocols: Cutler, Shade, and Klinghardt. Each varies in philosophy, method, and target population.
| Feature | Cutler Protocol | Chris Shade Protocol | Klinghardt Protocol |
|---|---|---|---|
| Primary Philosophy | Frequent low-dose chelation to avoid redistribution | Phased detox with liver and GI support | Systemic detox including microbial, lymphatic, and energetic layers |
| Chelators Used | ALA, DMSA, DMPS (oral) | Liposomal glutathione, ALA, binders | Chlorella, cilantro, DMSA (optional) |
| Dosing Principle | Every 3–4 hours (even at night) | Phased cycles with adaptive doses | Less rigid; terrain-focused |
| Amalgam Requirement | Amalgams must be removed first | Supports pre- and post-removal phases | Can be started before amalgam removal |
| Binders Emphasized | Not initially | Yes: thiol silica, charcoal, clay | Yes: chlorella, pectin, carbon |
| Best For | DIYers, chemically sensitive | Supplement-savvy individuals | Complex cases (Lyme, mold) |
| Drawbacks | Strict timing, sleep disruption | Requires organ support knowledge | Complex, hard to self-manage |